I Was Always Curious Why My Mother Hated Her Neighbor, but When He Died, I Found Out the Real Reason – Story of the Day

Share this:

I returned to my childhood home for only one reason: to get my mother, take her away, and never come back. But one question still haunted me — why had my mother hated our old neighbor so much? I never got an answer growing up. But today, when I finally stepped inside his house, I found the truth — a truth I wished I had known years ago.

As I pulled up the long driveway, a flood of emotions hit me all at once. There it was — the same old house I grew up in. A little worn down, with peeling paint and a cracked front step, but still standing proud like a tired old soldier.

I climbed out of the car and just stood there for a moment, breathing in the smell of the garden — roses, dirt, and something else, something old and familiar, like the wood of the front porch baking in the sun.

Suddenly, memories rushed at me like a wave. Birthday parties, scraped knees, cold winter mornings, and loud fights that always left me crying alone in my room.

The last time I’d been here was years ago, during a family get-together that felt more like a chore than a celebration. I had kept my distance after that, burying myself in my job, my busy city life, my friends — all the things that had felt so important at the time.

Deep down, I knew I should have visited more. But the truth was, my mother and I were never close.

Susan — my mother — was a tough woman. Strong opinions, sharper tongue. As a kid, I was scared to open up to her. And as she grew older, our talks just got harder and colder. Every conversation felt like stepping into a minefield. Easier to stay away.

But time has a way of changing things. Lately, when we spoke on the phone, I could hear the weariness in her voice. She talked about how the house was too much for her, how just getting groceries wore her out. Her words came slower, her energy weaker. I knew it was time to bring her closer to me — to a safer place where she wouldn’t have to struggle.

Strangely, she only agreed to move after her neighbor, Jeremy, passed away. Jeremy — the man she always hated.

I never understood why.

Growing up, I remembered her strict warnings:
“Stay away from Jeremy’s yard!”
“Don’t talk to him, Lisa!”

But to me, Jeremy had always been gentle. He had a soft smile, kind eyes. He once gave me candy when I fell off my bike. Nothing creepy, nothing scary — just kindness.

After a while, I stopped asking questions about him. I just followed my mother’s rules because arguing only brought more fights.

Still, even now, a part of me always wondered — why did she hate him so much?

Dragging my bags behind me, I took a deep breath and walked toward the front door, staring up at the house that had seen all my firsts — my first steps, my first heartbreak, my first taste of real fear.

The moment I pushed open the door, a wave of memories — and that same old smell of lavender mixed with wood — hit me.

Almost immediately, I heard her voice, sharp and familiar, calling down from upstairs:
“Lisa, is that you?”

“Yes, Mom! Are you packing already?” I called back, trying to sound cheerful.

“I still need time! Clean up downstairs!” she barked, her voice holding that same impatient edge it always had.

I looked up the stairs and hesitated. Maybe I should offer to help? Maybe, just maybe, we could share a moment — no fighting, no sharp words.

“How about I help you, Mom? It’ll go faster,” I offered.

“No!” she snapped immediately. “Did you hear me? Stay out of here — I’ll do it myself!”

I sighed, defeated. Same old Mom. Some battles just weren’t worth fighting.

“Alright, Mom,” I muttered under my breath, rolling my eyes as I dropped my bags by the living room.

I wandered around, my fingers brushing over dusty shelves packed with old knick-knacks and family photos. My hand paused over a photo of me, Mom, and Dad on some long-forgotten vacation.

I studied the photo closely. My dad — tall, brown-eyed, warm. My mother — sharp-eyed, strong. But me? My green eyes stood out, so different from both of them. As a child, I noticed, but I never dared to ask.

Dad had died in an accident when I was still young. After that, it was just me and Mom — or rather, Mom barking orders and me trying to survive them.

Carefully, I packed the photo into a box and moved toward my old bedroom.

Opening the door, I was hit by the sight of faded posters, an old desk, and a dusty wardrobe. I pulled the wardrobe open and, tucked way in the back, found something that made me smile: Mr. Peebles, my old teddy bear.

Jeremy had given me Mr. Peebles. I remembered the day clearly — it was raining, and I was crying after losing my favorite doll. Jeremy had knelt down and handed me the soft bear, saying with a smile,
“Every brave girl needs a brave bear.”

I had clutched Mr. Peebles to my chest like a lifeline.

But when Mom found out, she was furious. She grounded me for a week and screamed,
“You are to NEVER accept anything from that man! Throw it away!”

Of course, I couldn’t. I hid Mr. Peebles deep in my wardrobe, and there he stayed, my quiet secret friend.

Holding the bear now, brushing the dust off his worn fur, a feeling of deep curiosity grew inside me. Why had she hated Jeremy so much? There had to be a real reason, something bigger than she ever told me.

Feeling restless, I walked back to the staircase and shouted up:
“Mom! How much longer?”

“An hour… maybe more!” she called back, her voice faint.

I sighed loudly. Typical.

“I’m going for a walk, then!” I yelled.

“Fine! But don’t wander too far!” she warned.

“Mom, I’m 42 years old! I think I’ll survive,” I teased.

“Old habits die hard,” she grumbled from upstairs.

I chuckled and shook my head. Some things would never change.

I stepped outside, breathing in the cool air. My eyes automatically drifted to Jeremy’s old house, now empty and silent.

It looked so lonely — like it was holding its breath, waiting for someone to remember it.

On impulse, I walked over and tried the front door. To my shock, it swung open easily with a long, rusty creak.

“Hello? Anyone here?” I called out. Nothing but silence.

The house was cold and smelled of dust and time. I stepped inside carefully, feeling like I was trespassing on someone’s memories.

Climbing the stairs, I found Jeremy’s bedroom — a small, simple room with a single bed and a nightstand.

On the nightstand was a dusty box. I brushed it off, revealing words neatly written on top:
“For Lisa.”

My heart stopped.
Me?

I hesitated for a second before opening the box.

Inside were piles of letters, old photographs, and a worn-out journal. I picked up one of the photos — and gasped.

It was Jeremy, much younger, smiling with his arm around a woman — my mother.

They looked happy. Really happy.

Confused and trembling, I opened the journal. I flipped through the pages until one entry caught my eye — written on my eleventh birthday.

“Today was my dear Lisa’s birthday. Susan still won’t forgive me. I don’t blame her. When she needed me the most — when she told me she was pregnant — I ran away. I was scared. If I could turn back time, I would have been there for her… and for Lisa.”

I clutched the journal to my chest, my breath coming fast and shallow.

Jeremy… was talking about me.

I read on, tears blurring my vision:

“Today, I gave Lisa a teddy bear. She named him Mr. Peebles. I almost cried seeing her hug it. But Susan will probably take it away. I understand. I just hope, somehow, Lisa knows I love her.”

I dropped into the chair by the window, feeling the whole world tilt.

Jeremy had been my real father.

I wiped my face, reaching for the very bottom of the box where a sealed letter waited. I opened it with shaking hands.

“Dear Lisa,
If you ever read this, please know I always loved you. Not a day went by when I didn’t regret leaving. Please don’t blame your mother. She had every right to hate me. Everything that went wrong — it was my fault.
I leave you everything I have — the house, the savings. You are my only family.
Love always,
Jeremy.”

I cried then, hard and helpless, mourning a father I never truly knew — and the life we never got to share.

Folding the letter carefully, I tucked it into my pocket and walked slowly back to my mother’s house.

She was standing on the porch, bags packed at her feet, looking impatient.

“Lisa, where were you? I’ve been ready for ten minutes!” she snapped, then paused when she saw my red eyes.

“Lisa, are you okay?” she asked, sounding strangely soft.

“Yeah… just got some dust in my eyes,” I said, forcing a shaky smile. “Took me a while to wash it out. Ready to go?”

“Yes, honey. Let’s go. There’s nothing left for me here,” she said, almost whispering.

I looked at her — really looked at her — and for the first time, I saw not just my tough, stubborn mother, but a woman who had carried so much heartbreak alone.

“Don’t worry, Mom,” I said, squeezing her hand. “I’ll take care of you.”

We packed up the car and drove away, leaving behind the old house, the old wounds, and the secrets.

And even though the truth came late, it came just in time for a new beginning.