Our Dad Asked the Whole Family to Buy Mom Kitchen Utensils for Christmas as She’s a ‘Horrible Cook’ — We Decided to Outplay Him

Share this:

When my brother and I overheard Dad calling Mom “lazy” and making fun of her cooking, we knew right away we couldn’t let it go. What began as a simple Christmas gift list quietly turned into a clever plan—one that would teach him a lesson he’d never forget.

I never thought I’d say this, but our family Christmas this year felt like something straight out of a sitcom. Not the laugh-track kind at first, though. More like the kind that makes your jaw clench before everything finally explodes in a satisfying way.

My name is Stella. I’m fourteen years old, and my life is usually a mix of biology homework, arguing nonstop with my sixteen-year-old brother Seth, and trying—failing, really—to keep my white sneakers clean in a house that somehow always looks perfect.

And that perfection? That’s all because of Mom.

My mom, Lily, is the glue that holds our entire family together.

She works full-time, comes home tired, and still manages to do all the laundry, all the cleaning, and all the cooking. Somehow, she even finds the energy to help Seth with his physics projects, which honestly look less like schoolwork and more like tiny black holes covered in glitter glue.

Dad, meanwhile, proudly calls himself the “man of the house.”

In reality, that title mostly means sitting on the couch with his feet up, flipping through channels, and watching old action movies where everything explodes every five minutes. I love him—I really do—but he’s definitely a “comment on everything while doing nothing” kind of guy.

Still, none of that prepared us for what happened two weeks before Christmas.

Seth and I were creeping down the hallway, trying to find Mom’s hidden stash of wrapped presents. We were whispering and laughing quietly when we heard Dad’s voice coming from the bedroom. The door was closed, but he was talking loudly on the phone.

It was Uncle Nick.

“What should I get Lily?” Dad said, laughing like he was telling the funniest joke in the world. “Bro, just kitchen stuff. Mixers, blenders, utensils—anything that’ll make her actually useful in the kitchen. She’s soooo lazy in there.”

I froze. My stomach twisted so hard it felt like I might throw up.

Lazy?

Seth looked at me, his jaw tight. He whispered, “Dad can’t be serious.”

But he was.

Dad kept going. “I’m just saying, if she had better gadgets, maybe she wouldn’t be such a horrible cook. It’s not like she’s good at it anyway.”

That was it.

Something snapped inside me. Seth and I didn’t even need to talk. We quietly backed away from the door, went straight to his room, and shut it behind us.

“That was disgusting,” Seth said, pacing. “Mom does everything.”

“And he has the nerve to call her lazy?” I said. “Absolutely not.”

That night, we stayed up way past midnight, surrounded by notebooks, snacks, and pure anger. We called it Operation Outplay.

“First rule,” I said, pointing my pen at Seth, “no kitchen gadgets for Mom. She doesn’t even enjoy cooking—she does it because no one else will.”

Seth smirked. “Second rule. Dad needs to feel this. Deeply.”

I grinned. “Let’s start with an email.”

Together, we wrote to every family member coming for Christmas. The message was polite but firm:

“Hi, this is Stella and Seth. We need your help to make this Christmas really special for Mom. Dad suggested kitchen gifts, but we think she deserves so much more. Here’s a wishlist of things she’s always wanted but never bought for herself…”

We listed everything Mom had quietly admired over the years: a designer purse she always paused to look at, a spa day gift card, her favorite skincare products, a cozy reading chair for her tiny library corner, and a personalized necklace with our names engraved.

Then came the final line.

“Instead of getting Dad what he asked for, please buy him fishing rods. As many as possible. Trust us.”

The replies came fast.

Aunt Patricia wrote, “Count me in! Lily works so hard—it’s about time someone spoiled her.”

Grandpa replied, “Fishing rod it is. This will be fun.”

By the end of the week, everyone was on board.

Christmas morning arrived, and the house smelled like pine and fresh cookies. Mom had been awake since dawn, baking and refilling the coffee pot, her hair in that messy bun she called “practical,” even though it somehow always looked perfect.

Dad lounged near the fireplace, sipping hot chocolate like nothing had ever happened.

The whole family—twelve of us—sat in a circle around the tree. Gifts were passed around. Socks. Sweaters. Gift cards. Everyone smiled and laughed.

Then it was Dad’s turn.

Aunt Patricia handed him a box. “This one’s from me, Tanner.”

Dad opened it and blinked. “Oh. A fishing rod.”

“It’s top of the line,” she said sweetly. “Thought you’d love it.”

“Yeah… thanks,” Dad said, confused.

Then Seth handed him another box. “From me.”

Another fishing rod.

I handed him mine next. “Merry Christmas, Dad!”

He laughed nervously. “Wow. Three fishing rods?”

Then Uncle Nick. Aunt Claire. Grandpa.

By the fifth one, Dad snapped. “Okay, what is this? Who needs this many fishing rods? I don’t even fish!”

Meanwhile, Mom was opening her gifts. Her face lit up when she saw the designer purse.

“Oh my gosh,” she said softly. “This is beautiful. How did you know?”

Uncle Nick grinned. “The kids helped.”

Mom looked at us, eyes shining. “You did this?”

“You deserve it, Mom,” Seth said.

Her voice cracked. “This is the best Christmas I’ve had in years.”

Dad exploded. “Where are the kitchen gifts? She needs those!”

Mom froze. “You told everyone to get me kitchen stuff?”

Seth crossed his arms. “You called Mom lazy. We heard you.”

The room went silent.

Mom stood slowly, her voice shaking with anger. “So that’s what you think of me?”

Dad stammered. “I was joking!”

“I’m not laughing,” Mom said.

She picked up a fishing rod and dropped it into Dad’s lap. “Enjoy.”

The rest of the day was perfect.

That night, Mom hugged us tightly. “Thank you for seeing me,” she whispered.

Dad never called her lazy again.

Those fishing rods weren’t gifts.

They were a lesson.